In Dec. 2022, Emily was spotted kissing fashion designer and filmmaker Jack Greer outside her New York City apartment after rumors that she and Pete Davidson split. Just a few weeks prior, a source close to Emily shared with Hollywood Life that she wanted to pursue a casual, open relationship when split rumors with Pete emerged. "Emily is exploring single life, but it has no reflection on her connection with Pete," a source told the outlet. "She thinks he's great, she just isn't available for a commitment right now. They're still talking, it's just not exclusive."

Although it is unclear exactly how Emily and Jack Greer met, Emily shared on her "High Low" podcast that she has been using dating apps, which may have been a clue since this episode aired the same week she was spotted kissing Jack Greer. In the podcast, Emily stated, "I was like, 'F–k it. I was feeling defiant because so many people told me not to get it."

Interestingly enough, neither party ever spoke publicly about their relationship and the NYC kiss the two shared together was the only public appearance caught by paparazzi.