Tad Starsiak and Anna Spiars have largely kept the details of their relationship private, with little being known about the start of their romance. However, based on social media, it appears the two first started dating around May of 2022, with Spiars sharing a celebratory anniversary post the following year in 2023.

On the final episode of "Good Bones," Starsiak mentioned that the couple bonded over their shared interest in high fantasy, with their first date being a movie marathon of the J.R.R. Tolkien movie adaptations. Because of this, the contractor incorporated nods to fantasy elves and hobbits in both his engagement ring and in some design elements of their new home.

Other than that, the two have shared some important relationship moments on Instagram, with Starsiak posting a collection of photos from his 29th birthday celebration that included a snuggly photo of him and Spiars. In honor of their anniversary, Spiars similarly shared a host of snapshots from different moments in their relationship, including a photo from New Year's celebrations and a pic of them reading together. "Happy anniversary, darling," she wrote. "You are everything I dreamed."